Recruitment operations in the UK vs the US: A comparative analysis

Both the UK and the US boast diverse and dynamic economies, necessitating staffing solutions across a broad spectrum of industries, from technology and finance to healthcare and manufacturing. As major players in the global market, both countries feature highly competitive and rapidly evolving job markets, supported by a vast array of recruitment agencies ranging from large multinational firms to specialized niche agencies. 

However, despite these similarities, navigating the staffing markets in the UK and the US requires an understanding of some key differences that can significantly impact recruitment operations. In this blog, we will explore these distinctions to help businesses and candidates effectively engage with recruitment agencies in each country. 

Regulatory Frameworks 

UK:

  • The recruitment industry is regulated by laws such as the Employment Agencies Act 1973 and the Conduct of Employment Agencies and Employment Businesses Regulations 2003. 
  • IR35, or the “Intermediaries Legislation,” is a set of off-payroll working rules in the UK that applies to companies, intermediaries, and independent contractors. Its purpose is to determine whether a contractor is genuinely self-employed or should be classified as an employee for tax purposes. 
  • Recruitment agencies must comply with strict guidelines regarding candidate treatment, fees, and contracts. 
  • There are industry bodies like the Recruitment and Employment Confederation (REC) that set standards and offer certifications. 

US: 

  • The recruitment industry is less regulated at the federal level, with more emphasis on state regulations. 
  • Agencies must comply with various labor laws like the Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA) and the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC) guidelines. 
  • Industry bodies like the American Staffing Association (ASA) provide standards and certifications, but membership is not mandatory. 
Business Models 

UK: 

  • Recruitment agencies in the UK often operate on a contingency fee basis, meaning they are paid only if a candidate they present is hired. 
  • Retained search is also common, where agencies are paid an upfront fee to conduct a specific search, usually for higher-level positions. 
  • Temporary staffing is a significant part of the UK market, with agencies providing temporary or contract workers to businesses. 

US: 

  • Similar to the UK, many agencies operate on a contingency basis, but retained search is more prevalent, especially for executive positions. 
  • The US has a strong market for both temporary staffing and direct hire placements, with a significant focus on the gig economy and contract work. 
  • Recruitment Process Outsourcing (RPO) is also a growing trend, where companies outsource their entire recruitment process to an agency. 
Technology and Innovation 

UK: 

  • Recruitment agencies in the UK are increasingly adopting technology such as Applicant Tracking Systems (ATS), AI, and data analytics to enhance recruitment processes. 
  • There is a focus on GDPR compliance when handling candidate data. 

US: 

  • The US market is highly innovative, with widespread use of advanced recruitment technologies, including AI-driven sourcing, automated interviewing, and blockchain for credential verification. 
  • There is a significant emphasis on leveraging big data and analytics to drive recruitment strategies and decisions. 
  • While there is no GDPR equivalent at federal level, in states such as California for example have their own regulations.  
Market Dynamics 

UK: 

  • The UK recruitment market is highly competitive with a large number of small to mid-sized agencies. There are more than 30,000 recruitment businesses serving a population of 70 million. 
  • There is a strong focus on niche markets and specialized sectors, such as finance, technology, and healthcare. 

US: 

  • The US market is also competitive but dominated by several large national and international firms. However, there are still a lot less agencies, around 25,000 across a population of 360 million residents. 
  • There is a diverse range of recruitment sectors with strong growth in tech, healthcare, and engineering fields. 

While there are many similarities between recruitment agencies in the UK and the US, differences in regulation, business models, and technology adoption highlight the unique approaches in each country. Cultural differences need to be taken into account as well, but that can also differ from region to region within the US. Stay tuned for a blog on cultural differences. 

Thinking about expanding into the US market? Schedule a call with Lead and Gain.